Review: All the Missing Pieces by Catherine Cowles
I typically enjoy an insta-love romance, but this one felt forced, lacking the depth and complexity I’ve come to expect from Catherine Cowles.
The story follows Ridley, a true-crime podcaster driven by her twin sister’s unsolved disappearance. Her latest investigation brings her to Shady Cove, where she meets Colt, the local sheriff. While they initially clash, they soon find themselves working together to solve a case with ties to Ridley’s past.
What Worked:
- Ridley’s character: Her determination and personal stakes made her an engaging protagonist.
- The mystery: The cold case investigation kept me intrigued, even if it wasn’t groundbreaking.
- The cover: Absolutely stunning and eye-catching.
What Didn’t Work:
- The romance: The “enemies-to-lovers” banter quickly turned into insta-love, but the emotional connection between Ridley and Colt felt underdeveloped. Their chemistry seemed forced and didn’t evoke the swoony moments I hoped for.
- The dialogue: At times, it felt cheesy and unnatural, which made it hard to connect with the characters.
- The balance: The suspense plot was overshadowed by the romance, yet the romance didn’t have enough depth to carry the story on its own.
As a fan of Catherine Cowles, I know she’s capable of delivering layered, emotional romances, but this one didn’t hit the mark for me. While the mystery had some compelling moments, the romance fell flat, making the overall story feel formulaic.
